The clinical presentation of myocarditis is highly variable, and histopathology is thus considered to be the cornerstone of diagnosis. We studied how accurately myocarditis was diagnosed in a series of routine autopsies and how fatal myocarditis presents clinically. All death certificates with myocarditis recorded as the underlying cause of death in Finland in 1970 to 1998 were collected retrospectively (N = 639). All cases with cardiac autopsy samples and clinical data available (n = 142; median age, 51 years) were included in this study. The cardiac samples were reexamined for the presence of myocarditis by 3 experienced independent pathologists using the Dallas criteria. The clinical data were evaluated for the presenting signs and symptoms of myocarditis. Histopathologic reanalysis showed that only 32% of the 142 subjects met the Dallas criteria for myocarditis (75% of pediatric and 28% of adult patients, P = .001). Clinicians had suspected myocarditis in only one third of the hospitalized Dallas-positive patients. Dallas-positive patients presented more often with features of myocardial infarction (26% versus 9%, P = .026) or heart failure (35% versus 10%, P = .001) than Dallas-negative subjects. The signs and symptoms of infectious disease were also more common in Dallas-positive patients (61% versus 23%, P < .001). In contrast, Dallas-negative subjects died suddenly or were found dead more frequently (68% versus 39%, P = .004). The most evident cause of death in the Dallas-negative subjects was ischemic heart disease (n = 78, 55% of all cases). Our study provides evidence that myocarditis is overdiagnosed on routine autopsies, particularly in patients who have died suddenly or are found dead. Fatal myocarditis appears to present equally often as heart failure, sudden death, or mimicking myocardial infarction.