Table 3

Adjusted comparisons: early life exposures as predictors of ECD outcomes at 24 months of age

ECD outcomeUnstandardised coefficientsStandardised coefficients95% CI
BetaSEBetatP valueLower boundUpper bound
Visual acuity (n=622)
Constant0.340.311.110.27−0.260.95
Sex−0.010.01−0.06−1.260.21−0.040.01
Age at ECD assessment, months−0.020.01−0.092.180.03*−0.030.00
Maternal age at birth, years0.000.00−0.071.460.150.000.01
Parity0.000.000.02−0.340.73−0.010.01
Gestational age at birth, weeks0.000.00−0.06−1.480.140.000.00
LAZ12 −0.010.00−0.151.570.120.000.01
LAZ24 ** −0.010.00−0.31−2.94<0.001** −0.020.00
WAZ12 0.000.01−0.02−0.200.84−0.020.02
WAZ24 −0.010.01−0.121.180.24−0.010.03
HCAZbirth 0.000.01−0.050.900.37−0.010.01
HCAZ12 −0.010.01−0.16−1.580.11−0.030.00
HCAZ24 −0.010.01−0.121.190.24−0.010.03
SES0.000.00−0.03−0.560.57−0.010.00
Maternal education, years−0.010.00−0.41−7.95<0.001** −0.01−0.01
FCI: play activities0.000.00−0.01−0.240.81−0.010.01
FCI: household books0.000.01−0.02−0.370.71−0.020.01
Contrast sensitivity (n=627)Constant2.702.361.140.26−1.957.34
Sex−0.060.09−0.03−0.630.53−0.230.12
Age at ECD assessment, months−0.050.050.040.860.39−0.060.15
Maternal age at birth, years−0.010.010.020.600.55−0.010.03
LAZbirth −0.020.030.030.630.53−0.040.07
LAZ12 −0.010.030.010.170.87−0.060.07
LAZ24 −0.010.03−0.04−0.380.70−0.060.04
WAZ12 −0.030.08−0.03−0.380.70−0.200.13
WAZ24 −0.010.08−0.01−0.070.95−0.160.15
HCAZbirth −0.040.04−0.05−0.850.40−0.120.05
HCAZ12 −0.040.06−0.05−0.630.53−0.160.08
HAZ24 −0.050.06−0.060.760.45−0.070.16
SES−0.000.02−0.010.100.92−0.040.04
Maternal education, years−0.100.01−0.40−8.82<0.001** −0.12−0.08
FCI: varieties of play materials−0.020.03−0.020.470.64−0.050.08
FCI: play activities−0.030.02−0.05−1.240.22−0.080.02
FCI: household books−0.030.06−0.02−0.490.63−0.150.09
Cognition (n=667)Constant82.6643.421.900.06−2.67168.00
Sex−3.081.51−0.09−2.040.04*−6.06−0.11
Age at ECD assessment, months1.941.030.081.880.06−0.093.97
Parity−0.520.56−0.040.920.36−0.591.62
Gestational age at birth, week0.240.170.06−1.430.16−0.090.44
LAZbirth 0.140.600.020.240.82−1.041.33
LAZ12 0.050.540.010.080.94−1.021.11
LAZ24 0.790.490.17−1.630.10−0.161.74
WAZbirth 1.273.210.030.390.69−5.057.58
WAZ12 0.801.430.050.560.58−2.023.61
WAZ24 1.091.370.08−0.790.43−3.771.60
HCAZbirth 0.630.760.05−0.830.41−2.110.86
HCAZ12 0.081.050.010.070.94−1.982.13
HCAZ24 0.141.060.010.130.90−1.942.21
SES0.680.330.10−2.030.04*0.021.34
Maternal education, years1.090.200.28−5.63<0.001*0.711.48
FCI: varieties of play materials1.030.560.09−1.840.070.072.14
FCI: play activities0.530.390.06−1.360.180.241.29
FCI: household books0.321.030.01−0.310.761.712.35
Fine motor
(n=667)
Constant−1.021.36−0.03−0.750.46−3.701.66
Sex0.590.810.030.720.47−1.012.19
Age at ECD assessment, months0.530.450.101.190.24−0.351.41
LAZ12 0.820.410.18−2.020.04*0.021.62
LAZ24 0.001.310.000.001.00−2.572.57
WAZ12 0.831.200.06−0.690.49−1.533.49
WAZ24 0.430.900.04−0.470.64−2.201.35
HCAZ12 0.180.910.020.190.85−1.611.96
HCAZ24 0.120.280.02−0.450.66−0.660.42
SES1.140.520.11−2.190.03*0.122.16
Maternal education, years1.140.360.14−3.18<0.001** 0.441.83
FCI: varieties of play materials0.111.030.000.100.92−1.922.13
FCI: play activities0.500.850.02−0.590.56−2.161.16
FCI: sources of play materials1.021.360.03−0.750.46−3.701.66
FCI: household books0.590.810.030.720.47−1.012.19
Gross motor
(n=667)
Constant148.7048.523.060.0053.41243.99
Sex−1.851.79−0.04−1.030.30−5.371.67
Age at ECD assessment, months2.031.070.08−1.900.06−0.074.13
LAZbirth 0.680.690.070.980.33−0.682.04
LAZ12 0.620.620.091.000.32−0.591.83
LAZ24 1.710.540.29−3.18<0.001** 0.652.77
WAZbirth 6.233.480.11−1.790.07−0.5913.62
WAZ12 0.801.730.040.460.65−2.604.19
WAZ24 1.191.590.07−0.750.46−4.301.93
HCAZ12 1.151.190.080.960.34−1.203.49
HCAZ24 0.741.200.05−0.610.54−3.091.62
SES0.340.360.05−0.950.35−1.040.36
FCI: varieties of play materials1.200.620.09−1.950.05−0.012.42
FCI: play activities0.650.470.06−1.390.16−0.271.57
Language
(n=667)
Constant244.7752.444.670.00141.71347.82
Sex−7.111.93−0.15−3.69<0.001** −10.90−3.32
Age at ECD assessment, months2.021.320.06−1.530.13−0.484.61
Gestational age at birth, week0.120.210.02−0.580.57−0.540.29
LAZ12 1.080.670.131.600.11−0.252.40
LAZ24 2.190.600.34−3.65<0.001** 1.013.37
WAZ12 0.451.810.02−0.250.80−4.023.11
WAZ24 0.411.620.020.250.80−2.773.58
HCAZbirth 0.870.780.05−1.120.27−0.662.40
HCAZ12 0.430.860.030.500.62−1.262.12
Maternal education, years2.320.210.44−10.82<0.001** 1.902.74
FCI: play activities1.630.460.14−3.52<0.001** 0.722.54
FCI: household books2.231.280.07−1.740.08−0.294.75
Positive behaviour
(n=667)
Constant−27.6343.47−0.640.53−112.9957.73
Sex1.232.180.020.570.57−3.055.52
Age at ECD assessment, months0.741.380.020.540.59−1.963.45
LAZ12 0.530.670.06−0.800.42−1.840.77
LAZ24 1.370.560.182.460.01*0.282.46
SES1.030.460.112.270.02*0.141.93
FCI: varieties of play materials1.260.870.081.450.15−0.452.95
FCI: play activities0.210.600.02−0.340.73−1.380.97
FCI: sources of play materials2.631.750.061.510.13−0.806.07
Negative behaviour
(n=667)
Constant−41.7241.55−1.000.32−123.3139.88
Sex2.272.130.041.070.29−1.916.45
Age at ECD assessment, months−2.621.32−0.081.980.05−0.02−5.22
LAZ24 −0.610.30−0.082.010.05−0.02−1.20
FCI: varieties of play materials−1.500.69−0.092.180.03*−0.152.85
  • The SES tally provides the number of indicators available from the following list: electricity, improved water source, sanitation, synthetic flooring, improved cooking fuels, transportation and household assets.

  • *P<0.05, **p<0.001.

  • ECD, early child development; F, analysis of variance test statistic; FCI, family care indicators; HCAZbirth, HCAZ12, HCAZ24, WHO z-scores for head circumference at birth, 12 and 24 months; LAZbirth, LAZ12, LAZ24, WHO z-scores for length at birth, 12 and 24 months; SES, socio-economic status; WAZbirth, WAZ12, WAZ24, WHO z-scores for weight at birth, 12 and 24 months.