First author | Ref | Study design | Inclusion criteria* | Exclusion criteria† | Conservative treatment (n) | Appendicectomy (n) | Age (years) | Imaging method confirming the diagnosis (n/n total) | Duration of follow-up |
Hartwich | 13 | Prospective patient choice cohort | 5–18 years, symptoms <48 hours, ability to complete 7 days of oral antibiotics | Significant comorbidities, allergy to penicillin, inability to return to the hospital following recurrence/persistence | 24 | 50 | 12 0.5 (surgical), 13, 0.6 (conservative) (mean, SEM) | US (72/74), MRI (6/74) | 14 months (mean) |
Minneci | 14 | Prospective patient choice cohort | 7–17 years, symptoms <48 hours, WBC count <18 g/L, CRP <40 mg/L | Diffuse peritonitis, CRP >40 mg/L, pregnancy, chronic abdominal pain, faecolith or appendix diameter >1.1 cm on imaging | 37 | 65 | 12, 9–13 (surgical), 11, 10–14 (conservative) (median, IQR) | US (84/102), CT (28/102) | 21 months (median) |
Mudri | 15 | Retrospective physician choice cohort | 6–17 years, symptoms <48 hours | Symptoms >48 hours | 26 | 26 | 11 (surgical), 12 (conservative) (mean) | US (52/52) | NR |
Svensson | 16 | Unicentric randomised controlled trial | 5–15 years | Diffuse peritonitis, previous non-operative treatment of appendicitis | 24 | 26 | 11, 6–15 (mean, range) | US (50/50), CT (4/500) | 12 months (all, predefined) |
Tanaka | 17 | Prospective patient choice cohort | Age NR | – | 78 | 86 | 10, 5–15 (mean, range) | US (164/164), CT (n NR) | 3.3 years (surgical), 4.5 years (conservative) (median) |
Total | – | – | 189 | 253 |
*The diagnosis of appendicitis included imaging studies without signs of complication as inclusion criterion in all six studies.
†The suspicion of complicated appendicitis was an exclusion criterion in all six studies.
CRP, C-reactive protein; NR, not reported; Ref, Reference number as in reference list; US, ultrasound; WBC, white blood cells.