Study | Population(s) | Fever | Local reaction | Varicella like rash | ||||
Weibel et al 26 | 956 (1–14 y) | >38.9°C oral | (v) 27% at 48 h | (v) 4% at 8 wk | ||||
(v) = (p) = 2% per wk | (p) 19% at 48 h | (p) 2% at 8 wk | ||||||
Englund et al 56 | 111 (15–18 mth) | >37.8°C oral | 7% at 48 h | (v) = (p) = 2% at 6 wk | ||||
4 lost to follow up | (v) 35% (p) 36% | (p) 4% at 48 h | ||||||
Levin et al 57 | 202 (55–87 y) | >38°C | 1st injection 6% | 6/202 3% | ||||
<1% | 2nd 0% | Level II evidence | ||||||
Kuter et al 46 | 757 (13–54 y) | >37.8°C oral | 1st injection 19% | Post 1st: 8% | ||||
57 lost to follow up | 1st injection 10% | 2nd 31% | Post 2nd: <1% | |||||
2nd 7% | p > 0.05 | |||||||
Ramiksissoon et al 58 | 200 (9–24 mth) | — | Zero all groups | Total 2/200 1% | ||||
18 lost to follow up | ||||||||
Dose titration study | ||||||||
Tan et al 21 | 191 (9–24 mth) | Total 23% | Total 24% | Total 6/191 3% | ||||
Dose titration study | p > 0.05 | |||||||
Watson et al 47 | 111 (12–19 mth) | Total 6% | — | Total 5/111 4.5% | ||||
MMRV + (p) vs | 3.5% vs 5.6% | |||||||
MMR + (v) | ||||||||
Varis and Vesikari28 | 493 (10–30 mth) | Not defined | Not noted | To 4 weeks | ||||
Zero | (v) 4.5% (p) 3.7% | |||||||
Ngaiet al 31 | 2196 (1–12 y) | ⩾38.9°C oral | 24% vs 26% | 4% vs 1% | ||||
238 lost to follow up | 1 dose 15% | p < 0.001 | ||||||
2 doses 11% | ||||||||
Rothstein et al 29 | 150 (1–6 y) | >38.9°C oral | To 6 weeks | To 6 weeks | ||||
Dose titration study | 10–16%, p > 0.05 | 12–18% | 2–4% | |||||
White et al 49 | 494 (1–2.5 y) | ⩾38.9°C oral | To 6 weeks | To 6 weeks | ||||
(1st study) | MMRV + (p) | 25% vs 22% | 14% vs 12% | 7% both groups | ||||
MMR + (v) | ||||||||
White et al 49 | 318 (1–3.5 y) | ⩾38.9°C oral | To 6 weeks | To 6 weeks | ||||
(2nd study) | 2 lost to follow up | 23% vs 15% | 2.5% vs 2% | 17% vs 16% | ||||
MMRV vs MMR + (v) | ||||||||
Berger et al 55 | 200 (55–88 y) | Not defined | To 6 weeks | To 6 weeks | ||||
Zero at 72 h | (v) 36% (c) 66% | 1/200 |
(v), varicella vaccine group; (p), placebo group; (c), control group.