Article Text

other Versions

The relationship between maternal depression, in-home violence and use of physical punishment: What is the role of child behaviour?
  1. Michael Silverstein (michael.silverstein{at}
  1. Boston Medical Center, United States
    1. Marilyn Augustyn (augustyn{at}
    1. Boston University, United States
      1. Robin Young (ryoung{at}
      1. Boston University, United States
        1. Barry Zuckerman (barry.zuckerman{at}
        1. Boston Medical Center, United States


          Context: Maternal depression and in-home violence are independently associated with using physical punishment on children; however, the combined impact of these factors is unknown, as is the extent to which their relationship to physical punishment varies with child behavior. <PObjectives: 1) Determine the combined impact of maternal depression and violence exposure on one physical punishment practice, spanking; 2) Explore the role of child behaviors in this relationship.

          Methods Multivariable regression analysis of a nationally representative sample of US kindergarten children.

          Results: 12,764 mother-child dyads were analyzed. The adjusted odds ratio for spanking among mothers with depressive symptoms was 1.59 (95% CI 1.40, 1.80); among mothers exposed to in-home violence, 1.48 (1.18, 1.85); among dually exposed mothers, 2.51 (1.87, 3.37). Adjusting these models for child self-control or externalizing behavior yielded no change in these associations; no effect modification by child behavior was detected. Among mothers who spanked their children, depression was associated with an increased spanking frequency (aIRR 1.12; 1.01, 1.24); however, this association was reduced to borderline significance when adjusting models for child self-control or externalizing behavior (aIRRs 1.10; 1.00, 1.21). Depressed mothers who were also exposed to violence demonstrated higher rates of spanking (aIRR 1.29; 1.09, 1.53); this remained stable when adjusting for child behaviors.

          Conclusion: Maternal depression and violence exposure are associated with spanking as a means of punishment. The magnitude of this association is increased when the two occur together. Child self-control and externalizing behavior do not appear to impact substantially the association between maternal depressive symptoms, violence exposure, and spanking.

          Statistics from

          Request Permissions

          If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.