Background The widely used Mental Developmental Index (MDI) of the Bayley Scales of Infant Development-II has recently been superseded by the Bayley-III – in which cognitive and language development are assessed separately. Comparing developmental outcomes between cohorts assessed using two different editions of this test is problematic.
Aims To compare MDI and Bayley-III cognitive and language scores, evaluate the agreement between classifications of disability made using the two tests, and develop an algorithm for converting Bayley-III scores into corresponding MDI scores.
Methods 185 children (derived from a sub-cohort of the EPICure-2 study) aged 29–41 months were administered the MDI and Bayley-III concurrently. An average of Bayley-III cognitive and language scores (CB-III score) was calculated for comparison with MDI scores.
Results Bayley-III cognitive, language and CB-III scores were 3-, 10- and 7-points higher respectively than MDI scores, but the relationship was non-linear: the CB-III progressively overestimated developmental scores at lower MDI scores. Using a conventional cut-off score <70, CB-III scores under-detected developmental impairment compared with the MDI (sensitivity 58%, specificity 100%). Predictive validity was improved using a CB-III cut-off <80 (sensitivity 89%, specificity 99%). An algorithm was derived for transforming CB-III scores into MDI-equivalent scores, with further improvement in classification of children with MDI<70 (sensitivity 95%, specificity 97%).
Conclusions Caution should be exercised in classifying developmental outcomes using the Bayley-III for research purposes. To produce equivalent identification of children who would have an MDI <70, we recommend using a CB-III scores <80 or predicted-MDI scores <70.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.