Tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) is a multisystem genetic disorder stemming from unregulated activation of the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) pathway, resulting in the growth of hamartomas in multiple organs. TSC-related skin lesions often develop early in life and can be disfiguring, emotionally distressful and even painful at times. Recognition of TSC-associated skin features by paediatricians can be a catalyst for facilitating early implementation of treatment strategies and establishing appropriate follow-up care. The range of potential treatment options for symptomatic or disfiguring TSC-associated skin lesions includes non-pharmacological (surgical excision, laser therapy) and pharmacological (eg, topical or systemic mTOR inhibitors) alternatives. In this review, we discuss the relevance of TSC-associated skin findings, highlight available treatment options, review guideline recommendations and emphasise the role of the primary care physician in the management of this complex disease.
- mammalian target of rapamycin
- skin manifestations
- tuberous sclerosis complex
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) is a multisystem disorder that affects an estimated 40 000 individuals in the USA and approximately 2 million people worldwide, with a birth incidence of about 1 in 6000.1–3 Mutations in the tumour-suppressor gene TSC1 (encoding hamartin) or, more commonly, TSC2 (encoding tuberin) are implicated in the pathogenesis of TSC via a loss of inhibition of the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) pathway, allowing subsequent growth of hamartomas in various organs, including the brain (cortical tubers, subependymal nodules, subependymal giant cell astrocytomas (SEGAs)), kidneys (renal angiomyolipomas), lung (lymphangioleiomyomatosis (LAM)), heart (cardiac rhabdomyomas) and skin.4 ,5
Cutaneous findings are the most common and readily visible manifestation of TSC. More than 90% of patients with TSC have one or more skin lesions, which usually develop early in life.5 It is important for the paediatrician to be able to identify TSC-associated skin manifestations to ensure prompt diagnosis, early treatment initiation and appropriate referral for follow-up of other TSC-related sequelae. This review focuses primarily on cutaneous TSC-associated features, available treatment options and guideline recommendations regarding the management of patients with TSC.
Diagnosis of TSC
Outside of positive genetic testing confirming a pathological TSC1 or TSC2 mutation, the clinical diagnosis of TSC relies on a combination of identifiable major and minor characteristics, with cutaneous findings composing a large part of both major (hypomelanotic macules, angiofibromas, ungual fibromas, shagreen patch) and minor (‘confetti’ skin lesions) features (table 1).6 To establish a ‘definite’ clinical diagnosis of TSC, one must document either two major features or one major feature with two or more minor features. One can garner a ‘possible’ clinical diagnosis with the identification of either one major or two or more isolated minor features.6
Cutaneous manifestations of TSC are readily apparent upon thorough physical examination. In addition to internal organ evaluation, a detailed dermatological examination is recommended upon diagnosis of TSC, followed by at least annual skin examinations.7 Patients should be advised to use sun protection as a preventive measure to minimise the appearance of some skin lesions.
Clinical presentation of TSC-associated cutaneous manifestations
The subtypes of skin lesions tend to develop in an age-dependent manner, many arising early in life.8 Figure 1 provides a general timeline when certain lesions are more likely to be seen, allowing physicians examining paediatric patients to tailor their index of suspicion accordingly. Some cutaneous features can be subtle, especially in young children, and they are not all specific for TSC.
Facial angiofibromas, sometimes erroneously referred to as adenoma sebaceum, are the most visually apparent TSC-associated, often starting to appear within the first 2–5 years of life and ultimately occurring in approximately 75% of patients.9 ,10 They are usually pink to red-brown papulonodules with a smooth, glistening surface and are typically distributed symmetrically on the face, at times mistaken for acne (figure 2A).9 ,10 Angiofibromas start small and gradually increase in size, with their growth being augmented by puberty.10 Fibrous cephalic plaques are histologically similar and represent a larger variant of angiofibromas.9 ,10 They are raised, firm plaques, usually located on the forehead or scalp and have a tan to yellow-brown colour.9 Fibrous cephalic plaques, which can occur at any age, vary in size and shape and can grow to as large as several centimetres in diameter.9
Hypomelanotic macules are often the earliest and most frequently reported cutaneous finding in TSC.9 ,10 They present as hypopigmented macules and patches of various morphologies and should not be confused with de-pigmented patches seen in other pigmentary disorders such as vitiligo. In fair-skinned individuals, hypomelanotic macules can be difficult to identify, necessitating the use of a Wood lamp to make them more conspicuous.9 ,11 Medium to large (1–12 cm in diameter) hypopigmented patches are one of the earliest visible signs of TSC, occurring in >50% of children at birth and in nearly all patients by the age of 2.9 ,10 These patches are referred to as ‘ash leaf’ spots because they can resemble the leaf of the eastern mountain ash tree, shaped like a long oval with one rounded and one tapered end.9 ,10 Polygonal ‘thumbprint’-like macules are the most commonly observed morphology and are usually smaller (0.5–2 cm in diameter) than the ash-leaf type.9 Hypomelanotic macules appear asymmetrically and are most common on the trunk and buttocks. Scalp involvement is rare, but when present can lead to poliosis.9 ,10
‘Confetti-like’ skin lesions, another type of hypomelanotic macule, have been reported to occur in 2.8–28% of patients with TSC.9 ,10 ,12 These appear as numerous, small (approximately 1–3 mm in diameter) hypopigmented macules that occur symmetrically; they are typically spread over the distal extremities.9 ,10 Confetti-like skin lesions can appear any time from childhood to adulthood.6 ,9 ,10
Shagreen patches, a type of connective tissue hamartoma, are found in approximately half the patients with TSC. They typically develop during the first decade of life9 ,10 and are elevated pink to yellow-brown plaques with an orange peel–like texture, ranging from several millimetres to several centimetres in length (figure 2B).9 ,10 Shagreen patches are asymmetric and usually appear on dorsal surfaces, such as the back and the lumbosacral regions, but occasionally occur on the chest or the abdomen.9 ,10
Finally, periungual or subungual fibromas, also called Koenen tumours, are seen in approximately 15% of patients with TSC and are often observed in early adolescence.9 ,10 These nodules are often red to skin-coloured and typically appear near the proximal nail fold of the toenails (figure 2C) or, less commonly, the fingernails. One of the initial features of ungual fibroma is a nail groove without tumours.9 ,10
Treatment of TSC-associated cutaneous disorders
International TSC management guidelines recommend that any rapidly changing, disfiguring or symptomatic TSC-associated skin lesion be treated according to clinical context and type of lesion, using methods such as surgery, lasers or topical mTOR inhibitors.7 Determining the best approach to the treatment of cutaneous lesions also depends on clinical presentation, severity and presence of other TSC manifestations (table 2).7 ,13 In patients with growing SEGA, angiomyolipoma or LAM, treatment with systemic mTOR inhibitors, which address the underlying pathophysiology of the disease, might be indicated and is also likely to result in simultaneous improvement of skin lesions.13–16 However, systemic mTOR inhibitors can contribute to surgical complications and delayed wound healing;17–19 therefore, elective procedures (eg, cutaneous surgery, laser treatment) might best be avoided while on systemic therapy. In patients not receiving systemic treatment, topical mTOR inhibitors or surgical procedures may be indicated.
Systemic treatment with mTOR inhibitors
Rapamycin (sirolimus) and its analogues (eg, everolimus) inhibit the mTOR complex and,20 as a result, impede mTOR overactivation, which may shrink existing lesions and prevent tumour growth associated with TSC. Oral mTOR inhibitors have proved effective in the treatment of a range of TSC-related manifestations.14–16 Systemic mTOR inhibitor–associated adverse effects should be monitored, and commonly reported events include stomatitis, upper respiratory tract infection, wound healing complications and hypercholesterolaemia.21 ,22 If side effects become severe or intolerable, dose adjustments or interruptions may be necessary.21 ,22
Oral sirolimus is currently approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the European Medicines Agency (EMA) for the treatment of pulmonary LAM associated with TSC22 and is being studied for the treatment of cutaneous TSC-related manifestations.23–28 A recent retrospective study showed positive long-term effects of oral sirolimus on various skin lesions in 14 women being treated for TSC LAM.14 Of 11 patients with baseline photographs of their skin lesions, significant improvements were observed in angiofibromas and shagreen patches (p=0.018 and 0.039, respectively), but not in ungual fibromas (p=0.109), after median treatment durations of 12, 10 and 6.5 months, respectively.14 Three patients with angiofibromas and shagreen patches were observed after treatment cessation of between 6 and 48 months; shagreen patches, but not angiofibromas, worsened after treatment discontinuation.14
Oral everolimus has been evaluated in several studies of patients with SEGA, renal angiomyolipomas, LAM and epilepsy associated with TSC.15 ,16 ,29–35 Oral everolimus is approved by the FDA and EMA for the treatment of certain TSC-associated SEGAs and renal angiomyolipomas.21 The effect of oral everolimus on skin lesions was evaluated prospectively as a secondary endpoint in two pivotal phase III studies, EXIST-1 and EXIST-2.15 ,16 The skin lesion response rate, based on the Physician's Global Assessment, was significantly higher for everolimus than for placebo in both studies.15 ,16 The clinical experience gained from these trials indicates that oral everolimus is effective in improving cutaneous TSC lesions.16 Although thought to be effective in treating cutaneous TSC manifestations, oral mTOR inhibitors are currently reserved for patients whose internal disease warrants systemic treatment.
Non-systemic therapies (topical mTOR inhibitors)
Rapamycin (sirolimus) is a lipophilic compound22 that has been examined in numerous topical formulations of different concentrations and bases for the treatment of certain dermatological diseases. Studies demonstrate that topical mTOR inhibitors are effective for the management of several TSC skin lesions;36–40 however, no formulation is currently commercially available.
Consensus guidelines indicate that topical mTOR inhibitors are an effective treatment option for angiofibromas. They provide rapid response by flattening lesions and decreasing erythema. In some patients, particularly children with smaller lesions, almost complete resolution has been achieved.13 ,41 There are few known side effects of topical mTOR inhibitors, and they appear to be dependent on the formulation;36 ,40 blood drug levels are reportedly undetectable.13 ,42 Topical mTOR inhibitor solutions can cause skin irritation,13 ,36 which can be managed through dose reduction, addition of topical steroids36 or change of formulation to an ointment or gel. It seems that continual use is necessary for sustained benefit, but data on long-term safety and appropriate dosing are still lacking.
A recent review analysed 16 reports of topical rapamycin for the management of angiofibromas, which included ointments, gels, solutions and creams, with rapamycin concentrations ranging from 0.003% to 1%.36 Treatment was associated with moderate to complete clearance of lesions in 94% of the cases identified. Furthermore, no recurrences were seen with continued use; the longest treatment duration was 30 months. In most cases, side effects were absent, with the exception of cutaneous irritation, which was mainly restricted to patients using topical rapamycin formulated as a solution. Laser therapy can be used adjunctively with topical rapamycin as an effective treatment option for facial angiofibromas.43 ,44 In addition to facial angiofibromas, topical rapamycin has been reported to be effective in the treatment of other cutaneous TSC findings. For hypopigmented macules, treatment is generally not necessary. However, for cosmetically sensitive areas such as the face, topical mTOR inhibitors have demonstrated improvement in some cases.37 ,38 Additionally, a single report shows improvement in subungual fibromas with topical rapamycin.39
Evidence on topical everolimus is limited to a case study of a 10-year-old girl treated for facial angiofibromas.40 A petrolatum ointment containing 0.4% everolimus was applied once daily, and positive results were seen after 3–6 months of treatment. However, angiofibromas worsened when the strength of topical everolimus was lowered to 0.1%, even when applied twice daily. The only notable adverse effect of this topical formulation was photosensitivity at the application site, which resolved in 2 days; systemic everolimus levels were not detected.
Before the advent of mTOR inhibitors, surgery and other non-pharmacological therapies were the mainstay of treatment for TSC-associated skin lesions and, in some cases, are still the treatment of choice. Erythematous lesions may respond well to pulsed-dye laser treatment, which may be enhanced by the addition of 5-aminolevulinic acid.13 ,45 ,46 Additionally, use of ablative lasers can be helpful for fibrotic lesions, and surgical excision can be appropriate for large symptomatic lesions.13 A range of surgical approaches has been used to treat facial angiofibromas, including dermabrasion, cryosurgery, curettage, shave excision and chemical peels.9 ,13 ,47 ,48
In patients with symptomatic or large periungual fibromas, the use of ablative lasers or surgical excision are reasonable options.13 ,49 It is important to counsel patients that even with surgical removal, recurrence is possible.50 In patients who are not candidates for surgery, the use of carbon dioxide laser or other ablative laser treatments of periungual fibromas might be effective.51 Shave excision of the tumour followed by phenol application is another treatment option.49 ,52 In patients with shagreen patches, the levelling of elevated lesions with a Reese dermatome might be a viable cosmetic treatment option.53 For fibrous cephalic plaques that are disfiguring or rapidly progressing, surgical intervention is occasionally necessary.13
General paediatrician role in management
Paediatricians should be knowledgeable about the diagnostic criteria and cutaneous signs of TSC in order to facilitate timely diagnosis. Also, because TSC-related manifestations can change during the course of a patient's illness, ongoing surveillance is important to account for the potential emergence of new or progressing sequelae.7 In addition to new or growing tumours and cutaneous lesions, many patients with TSC exhibit tuberous sclerosis–associated neuropsychiatric disorder (TAND), which include behavioural symptoms and psychiatric, intellectual, academic, neurological and psychosocial manifestations.54 ,55 These can be assessed using a TAND checklist, which is administered by the clinician to the parent and/or child with TSC.54 Paediatricians should be aware of these symptoms and educate patients and their parents on available services and treatments. Given that TSC is a multisystem disease, the comprehensive assessment, surveillance and treatment of these patients will necessitate orchestration of multidisciplinary approaches involving numerous subspecialties, including dentistry, neurology, nephrology, dermatology, cardiology, ophthalmology and pulmonology (primarily in adult females), to monitor and treat TSC-associated manifestations.7 Consensus guidelines recommend a thorough baseline assessment of patients with newly diagnosed or suspected TSC, followed by ongoing monitoring of those with a definite or probable diagnosis (table 3).7
Paediatricians also play an important role in educating families about the genetic basis of TSC, ordering genetic tests, reviewing considerations for parental evaluations for TSC, instructing parents about potential implications for other family members and consideration of referral for genetic counselling.
Skin lesions are frequently reported in individuals with TSC and are potentially disfiguring, painful or emotionally distressing. The advent of targeted therapy with mTOR inhibitors has proved promising for the treatment of TSC-associated skin lesions. Although topical formulations of mTOR inhibitors seem to be better tolerated than systemic therapies, adequately powered and controlled prospective studies are necessary to confirm the efficacy and safety of topical sirolimus or everolimus in various subtypes of TSC-associated skin manifestations. Oral mTOR inhibitors, approved to treat internal manifestations of TSC such as SEGAs and renal angiomyolipomas, have also been effective in cutaneous disease.
TSC is a lifelong disease in which tumours may develop in multiple organ systems over a patient's lifetime; therefore, early diagnosis is paramount. Many types of TSC-associated skin lesions can develop at birth or during early childhood, highlighting the role of the paediatrician in the diagnosis of the disease. Therefore, awareness in the paediatric community of TSC-associated skin lesions is critical to ensure that patients receive an early diagnosis and systemic workup, timely initiation of treatment strategies and appropriate referrals for follow-up care.
Editorial assistance was provided by Maxwell Chang and Traci Stuve of ApotheCom (Yardley, Pennsylvania, USA).
Funding Editorial assistance was funded by Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation.
Competing interests None.
Patient consent Parental/guardian consent obtained.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.