Geographic region | Country | Author, year | Programme name | Study design | Study population and setting | Time period | Programme components | AARR | Effective programme |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Asia | Bangladesh | Smith et al 17 | Strengthening household ability to respond to development opportunities (Shouhardo) | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 6–24 months, poorest household | 2006–2010 | Nutrition education and counselling; GMP; Vit A and IFS; immunisation; HFP, access to local health facilities; sanitation; women empowerment; PFSA; SSN | 4.5 | Yes |
Bangladesh | Arifeen et al 18 | Integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) programme | Cluster randomised trial | Rural children 0–59 months | 2000–2007 | Nutrition education and counselling; GMP; IMCI | 2.9 | No | |
Cambodia | Ikeda et al 19 | National nutrition programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 0–59 months | 2000–2010 | IYCF; MNP; IMCI; parental education; HFP; WASH; reduction of maternal tobacco use | 1.03 | No | |
India | Haddad et al 20 | Integrated child development services programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 6–24 months, poorest household | 2006–2012 | Nutrition education and counselling; IYCF; Vit A and IFS; immunisation; IMCI; FF and FS; deworming; PFSA; SSN; HFP; women empowerment, child psychosocial stimulation; community kitchen and garden; telemedicine; WASH; | 2.2 | No | |
Nepal | Bilukha et al 21 | The vita-mix-it distribution programme | Pre–post design | Bhutanese children 6–59 months, Nepal refugee camps | 2007–2010 | Nutrition education and counselling; MNP; FS; GMP; immunisation; deworming | 4 | Yes | |
Vietnam | Khan et al 22 | National childhood malnutrition control programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 0–59 months | 1990–2004 | Immunisation; IMCI; PFSA; HFP; WASH | 4.3 | Yes | |
Latin America | Brazil | Lima et al 23; Monteiro et al 24; Victora et al 25 | National health and nutrition programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 0–59 months, poor household | 1986–2006 | PFSA; SSN; IMCI; parental education; WASH; HFP | 8.4 | Yes |
Haiti | Ayoya et al 26 | National health and nutrition programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 0–59 months, poor household | 2006–2012 | IYCF; Vit A and IFS; IMCI, immunisation; IMCI; FF; SSN; HFP; WASH | 1.05 | No | |
Mexico | Rivera et al 27; Leroy et al 28 | Oportunidades programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 0–24 months, poor household | 1988–2006 | Nutrition education and counselling; immunisation, GMP; FS and FF; SSN, women empowerment | 2.9 | No | |
Peru | Lechtig et al 29 | The good start in life programme | Before-and-after design | Rural poor children 0–36 months | 2000–2004 | Nutrition education and counselling; GMP; IYCF; Vit A and IFS; immunisation; FF; WASH, child psychosocial stimulation | 4.3 | Yes | |
Africa | Ethiopia | Fenn et al 30 | The child caring practices project | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 6–36 months, poor household | 2004–2009 | Nutrition education and counselling; IYCF; MNP; IMCI; immunisations; SSN; HFP | 2.42 | No |
Malawi | Kalimbira et al 31 | Integrated community-based micronutrient and health programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Rural children 6–59 months, poor household | 1996–2005 | Nutrition education and counselling; Vit A and IFS; FF; deworming; malaria prevention and treatment; WASH; HIV testing and referral | 2.4 | No | |
Niger | Amouzou et al 32 | Child survival programme | Cross-sectional surveys | Children 0–59 months, poor household | 1998–2009 | Malaria prevention and treatment | 3.3 | Yes | |
Sub-Saharan Africa | Remans et al 33; Pronyk et al 34 | Millennium village | Cross-sectional surveys | Rural children 0–24 months, poor household | 2006–2009 | Nutrition education and counselling; GMP; IYCF; Vit A and IFS; MNP; immunisations; IMCI; PFSA; access to local healthcare; WASH; telemedicine; malaria prevention and treatment, SSN | 6.7 | Yes |
AARR, average annual rate of reduction; FF, food fortification; FS, food supplementation; GMP, child growth monitoring and promotion; HFP, health and family planning services; IYCF, infant and young child feeding; MNP, multiple micronutrient powder; PFSA, Poverty and food security alleviation; SSN, Social safety net; Vit A and IFS, vitamin A and iron-folic acid supplementation; WASH, water, sanitation and hygiene.