Article Text

other Versions

Assessment of doctors‘ consultation skills in the paediatric setting: the Paediatric Consultation Assessment Tool.
  1. Rachel J Howells (rachel.howells{at}
  1. Plymouth Hospitals NHS Trust, United Kingdom
    1. Helena A Davies
    1. University of Sheffield, United Kingdom
      1. Jonathan D Silverman
      1. University of Cambridge, United Kingdom
        1. Julian C Archer
        1. Peninsula College of Medicine and Dentistry, United Kingdom
          1. Andrew F Mellon
          1. City Hospitals Sunderland NHS Foundation Trust, United Kingdom


            Objective: To determine the utility of a novel paediatric consultation assessment tool (PCAT)

            Design: Developed to measure clinicians' communication behaviour with children and their parents/guardian, PCAT was designed according to consensus guidelines and refined at a number of stages. Volunteer clinicians provided videotaped real consultations. Assessors were trained to score communication skills using PCAT, a novel rating scale.

            Setting: Eight UK paediatric units.

            Participants: 19 paediatricians collected video recorded material; a second cohort of 17 clinicians rated the videos.

            Main outcome measures: Itemised and aggregated scores were analysed (means and 95% confidence intervals) to determine measurement characteristics and relationship to patient, consultation, clinician and assessor attributes; generalisability coefficient of aggregate score; factor analysis of items; comparison of scores between groups of patients, consultations, clinicians and assessors.

            Results: 188 complete consultations were analysed (median per doctor = 10). 3 videos marked by any trained assessor are needed to reliably (r>0.8) assess a doctor's triadic consultation skills using PCAT, 4 to assess communication with just children or parents. Performance maps to two factors – 'clinical skills' and 'communication behaviour'; clinicians score more highly on the former (mean ± 95% CI = 0.52 ± 0.075). There were significant differences in scores for the same skills applied to parent and child, especially between the ages of 2 and 10 years, and for information sharing rather than relationship building skills (2-tailed significance <0.001).

            Conclusions: The Paediatric Consultation Assessment Tool appears to be reliable, valid and feasible for the assessment of triadic consultation skills by direct observation.

            Statistics from

            Request permissions

            If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.