Article Text

PDF

Understanding the rising incidence of type 2 diabetes in adolescence
  1. J Weill1,
  2. S Vanderbecken3,
  3. P Froguel2
  1. 1Paediatric Endocrine Unit, University Hospital, Lille, France
  2. 2Institute of Biology–CNRS UMR 8090, Institut Pasteur de Lille, Lille, France
  3. 3Paediatric Department, Saint-François d’Assise Foundation, Saint-Denis, Réunion Island, France
  1. Correspondence to:
    Prof. P Froguel
    Institute of Biology–CNRS 8090, Institut Pasteur de Lille, 1 rue Calmette, 59 000 Lille, France; philippe.froguelmail-good.pasteur-lille.fr

Statistics from Altmetric.com

A focus on its epidemiology, pathology, and therapeutic consequences

The definition of diabetes mellitus (DM) was recently changed by the American Diabetes Association to a fasting plasma glucose value of at least 126 mg/dl (6.9 mmol/l), on the basis of increased risk of the complication of retinopathy.1 It has been estimated that worldwide approximately 154 million people have diabetes,2 with up to one third of the cases remaining undiagnosed in developed countries such as the USA.3 Its human cost is considerable with morbidity from retinopathy, neuropathy, renal failure, and vascular disease, in addition to the socioeconomic burden. Additional lifetime health costs attributable to DM have been estimated at £19 649 per affected individual in the UK.4

Since the introduction of insulin therapy, a clear distinction has been established between the form of DM where insulin is immediately needed (type 1 or insulin dependent DM), and that where there is a danger of hypoglycaemia, where insulin therapy represents a “luxury” (type 2 diabetes (T2D) or non-insulin dependent DM). The latter is far more frequently associated with obesity and a “gluttonous appetite”.5 Age is a distinguishing feature: an age ⩾40 years predicts T2D with a sensitivity of 97% and a specificity of 100%.6

However, nearly 25 years ago, North American authors first drew attention to the occurrence of T2D in young Pima Indians.7 Pinhas-Hamiel from Cincinnati highlighted the incidence of this condition in black adolescents;8 subsequently Hispano-American adolescents have been found to be affected. This concerned US health authorities sufficiently for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to order a specific committee to investigate.10

EPIDEMIOLOGY

In greater Cincinnati, the incidence of T2D among young people suddenly increased from 0.3–1.2/100 000 new cases per year before 1992 to 2.4/100 000 by 1994 (one third of all juvenile DM cases). Black adolescents, especially females were mainly affected, but whites were not spared. Almost all patients were overweight, but there was no apparent link between body mass index in obese individuals, and incidence.8 Prevalence rates were recently reassessed as 0.41% of teenagers in the USA,11 and more specifically, in a population of US obese adolescents and children, the prevalence of impaired glucose tolerance and silent T2D was estimated as 25% and 0.4% respectively, independent of ethnicity.12

In the Far East, the prevalence dramatically increased for Japanese schoolchildren between 1975 and 1980 from 1.3 to 6 per 100 000.13 In UK (West Midlands and Leicester), eight T2D affected female teenagers were first identified from non-native ethnic minority groups—Pakistani, Indian, and Arabic,14 but recently Drake et al described in this journal the condition in four white significantly obese adolescents.15 Furthermore, in the southern hemisphere several cases have been found in obese adolescents on the islands of Polynesia and Réunion which are French Overseas Departments (P Froguel, unpublished data).

PATHOLOGY

In order to understand the mechanisms of T2D in adolescence, one has to take into account epidemiological data, ethnicity, and obesity, as well as puberty status and insulin secretion. There is a complex interplay of factors, essentially linked to lifestyle and genetics.

Ethnicity

Carbohydrate metabolism is influenced by ethnicity. For example, post-pubertal Mexicans show a bimodal glucose profile two hours after a glucose challenge. The first bell shaped distribution is seen in the majority, but a minority of the group have a separate, frankly diabetic curve.16 Resting energy expenditure and to a greater degree basal lipolysis are significantly lower in Afro-American prepubertal normal children than in their white counterparts.17,18

Anthropometry and insulin resistance

Obesity

Resistance to the hypoglycaemic action of insulin is a prerequisite to glucose intolerance and T2D.12 Insulin resistance is more marked in normal black than normal white adolescents.19 Obesity causes, or at least, worsens insulin resistance, which is partially alleviated by diet induced slimming.20 Clinically, insulin resistance is shown by acanthosis nigricans, a velvety hyperpigmented cutaneous lesion, mainly located in the axillae and around the neck.15

The mechanism of insulin resistance in obesity is a matter of debate involving two confronting theories, metabolic and hormonal.

Metabolic: either endogenous or exogenous (supplied by food) non-esterified fatty acids, whose plasma levels are increased in obesity, antagonise glycolysis and thence glucose oxidation in skeletal muscles.21

Hormonal: obesity is characterised by an increase of plasma levels of adipocyte secreted diabetogenic hormones (leptin, cytokines such as tumour necrosis factor (TNFα), interleukin 6, and resistin) and by the decrease of an insulin sensitising hormone, adiponectin.22

Insulin resistance is not universal in obesity,12 even in children with early onset and when it is severe.23 T2D occurs when insulin secretion becomes unable to overcome the insulin resistance,12 resulting in variable insulin secretion defects, with a range of diabetes from silent to ketoacidosis.12,24

Intrauterine growth retardation

Children born small for gestational age and remaining short are characterised by insulin resistance,25 which is a risk factor for T2D. This emphasises the important influence of intrauterine development on later health.

Fetal macrosomia

Conversely, in the offspring of mothers with diabetes from predisposed American Indian tribes, macrosomia is predictive of future T2D of youth.27

Puberty

Longitudinal studies have shown a drop in insulin sensitivity in late puberty, irrespective of changes in body fat, visceral fat, plasma insulin-like growth factor 1, or sex steroid levels.27 This reduced insulin sensitivity is probably due to a sex hormone primed increase in growth hormone secretion.28

Lifestyle

Diet

The Japanese experience emphasises the role of saturated animal fats and proteins. The increase of juvenile T2D between 1975 and 1980 accompanied Westernisation of food, while the incidence of obesity progressed more slowly at that time.13 Saturated fats promote obesity29 and insulin resistance,21 and reduce insulin secretion by way of lipotoxicity, with hyperglycaemia exacerbating pancreatic beta cell damage by glucotoxicity.30

Physical activity

Physical training improves insulin sensitivity by increasing insulin dependent glucose transporter GLUT-4 expression in muscle.31 Furthermore, physical inactivity leads to an increased prevalence of obesity.32

Toxicology

Research from inner city Los Angeles minority patients with T2D showed that consumption of alcohol and illicit drugs hastens the onset of the disease.33

Genetics

A small proportion of patients presenting with T2D (5% at all ages) have a monogenic, autosomal dominant form of T2D (maturity onset diabetes of the young (MODY), 1–6 subtypes). These patients generally have a strong family history of T2D in two or more consecutive generations. They generally show an early onset of chronic hyperglycaemia. For instance, subjects with glucokinase deficiency (MODY 2) present with mildly raised glucose values in the first week of life.

In contrast, MODY 3 subtype (due to mutation in the transcription factor hepatocyte nuclear factor 3α) occurs at a later age, in general around or after puberty.34 In Caucasians, about 50% of all MODY cases have mutations in glucokinase, and this condition is not infrequent in children with abnormal glucose values and absence of pancreatic islet antibodies. In adolescents and young adults with severe non-type 1 diabetes, MODY 3 is the most prevalent MODY gene.

Recently, several papers have described atypical forms T2D in children or adolescents with “private” mutations in HNF1α.35–37 It is likely that besides HNF1, mutations in other key genes for β cell phenotype may have the same effect when present at a high prevalence in isolated populations experiencing an obesity epidemic.

Apart from MODY, T2D is a multifactorial disease, dependent on the complex interaction of environmental and genetic factors with the effects of multiple genes.38 A well documented Danish twin study assessed genetic predisposition for T2D itself as 61%, 26% for glucose intolerance, and 50% for an insulin secretory abnormality.39 In order to explain the higher incidence of T2D in diverse ethnicities, Neel proposed, in 1960, the thrifty genotype theory. Starvation selected genes efficient for energy storage, which are detrimental in affluent times, because of metabolic overload.40 At the present time, we are not aware of “original” thrifty genes in predisposed populations. The hypothesis of transethnically shared genes showing at-risk variants in a higher prevalence than in predisposed populations seems more likely. A recent example is the chromosome 2 NIDDM 1 CAP 10, encoding for the calpain 10 protease subtype. The same at-risk haplotype is present in more than 15% Mexican-Americans where it contributes to insulin resistance, compared to <5% in Caucasians where its effect on diabetes risk is marginal.34

Whether adulthood and childhood onset T2D are genetically distinct entities remains unknown. Given the constant presence of obesity in patients with T2D, it is tempting to speculate that genes conferring a high risk for obesity in children may be the same as those linked to early onset T2D. In this regard VNTR promoter polymorphism in the insulin gene, which was known to be associated with low birth weight and with T2D, was recently shown to be also linked to both excess weight in the general population and to massive childhood obesity41 (P Froguel, unpublished data). Positional cloning strategies, which imply the genome scanning of dozens of families with multiple cases of children with severe obesity, and the mutation screening of candidate genes mapping to the regions of linkage will contribute to identify these genes, if they exist.34 A recent wide genome scan of French families with childhood obesity has mapped a chromosomal region linked to both insulin resistance and obesity on chromosome 6q, at the same locus where a quantitative trait modulating glucose values was found in adults.42 The availability of large data sets of patients from various ethnic groups with early onset T2D will be necessary to search for susceptibility genes.

THERAPEUTIC CONSEQUENCES

Therapeutic interventions are based on the pathophysiology described above. Lifestyle changes, diet,43 and physical exercise, moderate but frequent, at least three times a week,44 constitute a prerequisite, but long term compliance is difficult to obtain in this age group. Oral medicines include insulin sensitisers and secretagogues. As a sensitiser, metformin (500 mg twice a day), compared to placebo, lowered fasting plasma glucose and HbA1C in adolescents with T2D, at the cost of transient abdominal discomfort and diarrhoea in some patients.45 Thiazolidinediones such as pioglitazone or rosiglitazone enhance insulin sensitivity in the liver, adipose tissue, and skeletal muscle. They reduce hepatic glucose output and increase muscle glucose uptake and can be used in combination with metformin, but age specific drug trials are needed.

Sulphonylurea insulin secretagogues act through binding to the β cell membrane receptor, to stimulate insulin output. For decades young people with diabetes suffering from the monogenic form MODY 2 responded to chlorpropamide, one of the older analogues,46 but trials remain to be conducted for newer drugs such as glibenclamide and gliclazide in multifactorial T2D of the young. Prandial glucose regulators such as repaglinide are used to control post-prandial hyperglycaemia in adults.47 Oral combination therapy is more efficient than monotherapy in lowering HbA1C.48

Immediate insulin is required when there is significant ketonuria at presentation, and later if blood sugar control is inadequate with HbA1C levels >7% in spite of intensive oral medication, dietary, and exercise management.49

Microvascular complications may be present from diagnosis in T2D.50 However, the aim is to achieve satisfactory blood glucose control, which may be difficult to adhere to in underprivileged minorities.51 Prevention of T2D through fighting obesity by reducing dietary fat intake and community led programmes to increase physical activity are political priorities for young people. The American “Diabetes Prevention Program Research Group” recently showed the efficacy of metformin and especially of physical activity in prevention of diabetes in T2D prone adults.52

A focus on its epidemiology, pathology, and therapeutic consequences

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.