Article Text

PDF

Randomised controlled trial of zinc supplementation in malnourished Bangladeshi children with acute diarrhoea
  1. S K Roya,
  2. A M Tomkinsb,
  3. S M Akramuzzamana,
  4. R H Behrensc,
  5. R Haidera,
  6. D Mahalanabisa,
  7. G Fuchsa
  1. aClinical Sciences Division, International Centre for Diarrhoeal Diseases Research, Dhaka, Bangladesh, bCentre for International Child Health, Institute of Child Health, London, cClinical Nutrition Unit, Department of Clinical Sciences, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London
  1. Dr S K Roy, International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh, GPO Box 128, Mohakhali, Dhaka 1000, Bangladesh.

Abstract

OBJECTIVE To evaluate the impact of zinc supplementation on the clinical course, stool weight, duration of diarrhoea, changes in serum zinc, and body weight gain of children with acute diarrhoea.

DESIGN Randomised double blind controlled trial. Children were assigned to receive zinc (20 mg elemental zinc per day) containing multivitamins or control group (zinc-free multivitamins) daily in three divided doses for two weeks.

SETTING A diarrhoeal disease hospital in Dhaka, Bangladesh.

PATIENTS 111 children, 3 to 24 months old, below 76% median weight for age of the National Center for Health Statistics standard with acute diarrhoea. Children with severe infection and/or oedema were excluded.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Total diarrhoeal stool output, duration of diarrhoea, rate of weight gain, and changes in serum zinc levels after supplementation.

RESULTS Stool output was 28% less and duration 14% shorter in the zinc supplemented group than placebo (p = 0.06). There were reductions in median total diarrhoeal stool output among zinc supplemented subjects who were shorter (less than 95% height for age), 239 v 326 g/kg (p < 0.04), and who had a lower initial serum zinc (< 14 mmol/l), 279 v 329 g/kg (p < 0.05); a shortening of mean time to recovery occurred (4.7v 6.2 days, p < 0.04) in those with lower serum zinc. There was an increase in mean serum zinc in the zinc supplemented group (+2.4 v −0.3 μmol/l, p < 0.001) during two weeks of supplementation, and better mean weight gain (120 v 30 g, p < 0.03) at the time of discharge from hospital.

CONCLUSIONS Zinc supplementation is a simple, acceptable, and affordable strategy which should be considered in the management of acute diarrhoea and in prevention of growth faltering in children specially those who are malnourished.

  • 20 mg of daily zinc supplementation reduced diarrhoeal stool in shorter children

  • Zinc reduced diarrhoeal stool in those with low serum zinc

  • Zinc reduced duration of diarrhoea in children with low serum zinc

  • Zinc increased body weight of children during acute diarrhoeal episode

  • Malnourished children are likely to benefit more from zinc supplementation

  • zinc supplementation
  • acute diarrhoea
  • weight gain
  • malnutrition

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Diarrhoea remains a major cause of morbidity and mortality in less developed countries.1 A significant proportion of children who suffer from diarrhoea are malnourished, and malnutrition is associated with increased severity and duration of diarrhoea in such children.2-4 These malnourished children are often reported to have associated micronutrient deficiencies.5-7 An association between zinc deficiency and impaired growth has also been observed. Furthermore, zinc is important in the control of growth of the intestinal mucosa.8 Zinc supplementation improves the transport of water and electrolytes across the intestinal mucosa in experimental zinc deficiency.9-11 Severe zinc deficiency syndrome in humans, known as acrodermatitis enteropathica, responds to treatment with oral zinc supplements.12 Castillo-Duranet al have reported that daily losses of zinc in the intestinal fluid during acute diarrhoea are as high as 159 μg/kg/day, compared with 47 μg in control children.13 Children with marginal nutritional status are at significant risk of developing zinc depletion with an episode of diarrhoea. Zinc is a constituent of more than 100 metalloenzymes and is essential for growth, protein synthesis, epithelial repair, and synthesis of RNA and DNA.14 Hence there are many reasons why zinc deficiency could affect intestinal function. Zinc has marked effects on T cell function15 and zinc supplementation improves immunity,16 17 which may reduce the severity of diarrhoea by limiting growth and multiplication of diarrhoeal pathogens in the intestine. We therefore hypothesised that zinc deficiency is prevalent in malnourished children with diarrhoea and that zinc supplementation would reduce the severity and duration of diarrhoea.

Methods

DESIGN

A double blind, randomised, controlled clinical trial was conducted in children with diarrhoea of less than three days’ duration who were admitted to the International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh. Children aged between 3 and 24 months were eligible for the study provided they had no systemic infection or oedema, and their weight was below the 76th centile of weight for age according to the National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) standard18 (by Gomez classification, protein energy malnutrition grades II and III are included).

SAMPLE SIZE

The sample size was determined on the assumption that zinc supplementation would decrease intestinal fluid losses at least by 20% and reduce the duration by 20%. The estimation of sample size was performed according to Kirkwood,19 taking the probability at the 5% level and assuming a power of 80%.

A block randomisation procedure was performed using a random table to assign eligible patients equally to a treatment group receiving zinc acetate with multivitamin syrup or the control group receiving only multivitamin syrup of the same basic ingredients (prepared by Square Pharmaceutical Co, Bangladesh). The syrups were identical in appearance and flavour and were packaged in identical containers. Randomised patient numbers were labelled on the bottles to maintain the double blind design. Fifty seven children received zinc and 54 received the multivitamin syrup.

CLINICAL PROCEDURES

On admission, dehydration was assessed using World Health Organisation (WHO) guidelines20 and corrected within four hours with either intravenous polyelectrolyte solution or WHO/Unicef oral rehydration solution. Body weight after rehydration was measured with a scale having a precision of 20 g on the day of admission and daily thereafter between 9 and 10 am. Supine length was measured on a locally constructed length board to a precision of 1 mm. Nutritional status was expressed as a per cent of the median NCHS standard. Shorter children were defined as less than 95% height for age.21Serum zinc concentrations were considered low if they were below 14 μmol/l (as found in malnourished and zinc deficient children).22

To examine a possible relation between serum zinc and diarrhoeal or nutritional outcome, children with hypozincaemia on admission were considered to be zinc deficient. However, as the number of children with very low serum zinc concentrations (below 10 μmol/l), was very small, the 66th centile value for serum zinc was taken as the lower cut off point for comparing the effect of zinc supplementation among the more zinc deficient children.

A normal hospital diet (milk/cereal/liquid diet, appendix ) was given ad libitum and breast feeding was encouraged. Zinc was given as 20 mg elemental zinc per day in three divided doses for a period of two weeks in a multivitamin syrup. This was prepared by Square Pharmaceuticals Co, Bangladesh, and contained in each 5 ml: elemental zinc 6.5 mg, vitamin A 3000 IU, vitamin D 600 IU, vitamin B-1 1.2 mg, riboflavin 2.0 mg, vitamin B-6 0.6 mg, nicotinamide 6.0 mg, and calcium d-pantothenate 6.0 mg. One millilitre of zinc syrup contained 1.3 mg of elemental zinc. The control group received the same multivitamin syrup but without zinc. The syrup was given by the mothers under direct continuous supervision of nurses during the hospital inpatient stay and by community health workers on alternate day home follow up visits.

LABORATORY INVESTIGATIONS

Blood samples were obtained on admission, after correction of dehydration, and at the end of the supplementation and were stored at −20°C. Urine was collected separately from stool using adhesive single use paediatric urine collection bags. Stool was collected in a preweighed container beneath a cholera cot and measured every eight hours on a sensitive scale to the nearest 1 g. Clinical recovery from diarrhoea was defined as the passage of a soft formed stool. Serum zinc was measured using an atomic absorption spectrophotometer (Pye Unicam, SP9) and serum retinol by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC, Waters 510, USA). Enteric pathogens were isolated according to the WHO manual for laboratory investigations of acute enteric infections.23 Informed written consent was obtained from the parents of all patients before inclusion of the children in the study. The study was approved by the ethics review committee of the International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research.

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

Data were recorded on questionnaires and transferred to coding sheets. Data cleaning, validation, and analyses were performed using SPSS/PC+, EPISTAT, and NCHS anthropometric software. Student’s unpaired and paired t tests were used on normally distributed data and the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test and Wilcoxon’s matched paired tests were used for stool weight and body weights of malnourished and zinc deficient children respectively, where the distribution was skewed. Statistical significance was considered to be at the 5% probability level.

Results

Fifty four subjects were allocated to control group not receiving zinc but only multivitamin syrup, and 57 subjects received zinc supplementation with multivitamins. The oral zinc supplementation was palatable and well accepted by the children and without any apparent complications.

Diarrhoeal pathogens were isolated in 67% of the children. Single infections were noted with rotavirus (25%), enteropathogenicEscherichia coli (7%), enterotoxigenic E coli (6%), Vibrio cholerae (2%), and shigella or campylobacter spp (7%). Fifteen per cent of the children had a mixed infection. The distribution of pathogens was similar between the zinc supplemented and placebo groups.

BASELINE COMPARISON

On admission, the mean values of the general characteristics of the children of the control group were comparable with those of the zinc supplemented group, for example: age, 11 v 11 months; per cent of median weight for age, 67 v 67; height/age, 92v 92; weight/height, 81 v 81; mid upper arm circumference, 11.6 v 11.3 cm; serum zinc, 12.6v 11.2 μmol/l; duration of diarrhoea before entry into the study, 2.6 v 2.8 days; proportion of shorter children, 78% v 87%; proportion of wasted children, 48%v 39%; proportion of children having lower serum zinc (as defined above), 74% v 75%. The distribution of male and female subjects were also comparable between the control and zinc supplemented group: M/F, 31/23 v 33/24.

The patients were followed after the discharge from the hospital to ensure completeness of their two week zinc supplementation. Sixteen children in the placebo group and 20 in the zinc supplemented group could not be located because they migrated following a flood in Dhaka city, the catchment area of the study patients. Hence analysis for the time to recovery and diarrhoeal stool weight was restricted to those whose second blood sample could be obtained, to ensure that they had received two weeks of supplementation.

CLINICAL OUTCOME

The median total diarrhoeal stool output (g/kg/day) was 28% less in the zinc supplemented group as a whole (p = 0.06). Zinc supplementation reduced median stool weight (279 v 326 g/kg, p < 0.04) in those children who had lower serum zinc (< 14 μmol/l) on admission. There was reduction in median total diarrhoeal stool output with zinc supplementation in the shorter children (< 95% height/age) compared to similar children receiving placebo (279v 326 g/kg, p < 0.049) (table 1).

Table 1

Impact of zinc supplementation on stool output in children during acute diarrhoea

The duration of diarrhoea was shorter by 14% (NS) with zinc supplementation among the entire group of children. Children with a lower serum zinc (< 14 μmol/l) achieved a 22% reduction (p < 0.04) in the duration of diarrhoea with zinc supplementation (table 2). No such difference in duration among the stunted or wasted children was found.

Table 2

Impact of zinc supplementation on duration of diarrhoea in days. Values are mean (95% confidence interval)

Weight gain at discharge and improved serum zinc levels were noted in the zinc supplemented children. The zinc supplemented group had gained in mean body weight (6.31 v 6.19 kg, p = 0.03) but there was no gain in the placebo group (6.46 v 6.43 kg, p = 0.68). The control group showed a slight reduction in mean serum zinc (12.6 v 12.3 μmol/l, p = 0.63), whereas the supplemented group had a significant increase in mean serum zinc (11.2v 13.6 μmol/l, p < 0.001) (table 3).

Table 3

Impact of zinc supplementation on weight gain and serum zinc levels during management of acute diarrhoea. Values are mean (95% confidence interval)

NUTRITIONAL OUTCOME

The body weight of the zinc supplemented stunted and wasted children increased by the time of recovery from diarrhoea. The change was significant in the supplemented stunted group (median 6.20 kg from 6.08 kg, p < 0.006) compared with their counterparts in the control group (6.27 kg from 6.28 kg, p = 0.7). Similarly in children who had lower serum zinc, the supplemented group had a significant increase in body weight (6.20 kg from 6.04 kg, p = 0.05) compared to the control group (6.23 kg from 6.31 kg, p = 0.49) (table 4).

Table 4

Impact of zinc supplementation on weight gain in stunted, wasted, and zinc deficient children. Values are median (range)

Discussion

Our study examined several aspects of zinc supplementation. Zinc deficiency in children with diarrhoea occurs as a result of increased zinc loss in the stool13 together with reduced dietary intake. Many studies have stressed that serum zinc is not a good indicator of overall zinc status.24 Yet we have been able to show clearly that our group of children with moderate to severe malnutrition showed a rise in serum zinc after supplementation, even when they were suffering from acute diarrhoeal illness. On the other hand, the group given multivitamins alone did not show any improvement in serum zinc concentrations. This result suggests that serum zinc does have value as an indicator of zinc nutrition. However, we do not know whether this rise in serum zinc is maintained. The significant rise in serum zinc following zinc supplementation suggested an improvement in zinc status. We feel that the quantity of zinc given, which was double the recommended nutrient intake, was adequate to allow a physiological effect despite the known reduction in absorption during diarrhoea.

The results of zinc supplementation might have been even greater if the control group had not received multivitamin syrup. However, the children were malnourished, and hence multivitamin supplementation during a diarrhoeal episode was appropriate. The WHO has suggested that children below 1 year of age are given 100 000 IU vitamin A at six month intervals, with an additional dose during diarrhoea. Our patients were given 126 000 IU vitamin A during their diarrhoeal episode over a 2 week period in both study groups. During diarrhoea, the absorption of vitamin A is significantly reduced, while the requirement in malnourished children is increased; hence the dose given to our children should have been adequate. The cost of the zinc and multivitamin syrup was £0.33 (US $0.50) per child for a two week course. In Bangladesh and most developing countries, a large majority of children suffer from malnutrition and they contract about three to four episodes of diarrhoea in a year. The study was conducted in a malnourished group of children who are likely to be depleted of endogenous zinc from earlier diarrhoeal episodes and low dietary intake.

As the number of children with any specific enteric pathogen was small, we analysed the results from all the children without stratifying them according to the type of pathogenic organism, assuming that with random allocation patients with particular pathogens would be equally distributed in the two groups. In doing this, we recognise that those with a limited response to zinc might dilute the effect of zinc on those with mucosal damage. None the less zinc supplementation reduced net fluid loss, as indicated by reduced stool weight among the shorter children and in those with lower serum zinc levels.

A recently published epidemiological study from India by Sazawalet al showed a 7% reduction in the proportion of episodes lasting more than seven days if zinc supplementation was given within three days of the onset of diarrhoea25 and the authors also documented a greater reduction (39%) in the duration of diarrhoea among the shorter children. The limitation of that study was that stool was not quantitated and was not under continuous observation for accurate recording of recovery. Home visits were made and a history of diarrhoea was taken from the caretaker of the child, whereas in our study there was 24 hour observation and meticulous weighing of stool output during the period of hospital management, while time to recovery was confirmed by direct observation. The study by Sazawal et al did not document the reduction in fluid loss during diarrhoea. It is noteworthy that the stool output of our study children varied over a wide range, perhaps because of the different stool pathogens. Our previous experimental animal studies8-10showed that zinc supplementation in zinc deficient rats resulted in an increase in mucosal mass and in absorption of water and sodium. It has also been well demonstrated that zinc supplementation improves the mucosal lesion in patients with acrodermatitis enteropathica.26 27

Zinc deficiency in children has been associated with dwarfism and it is well recognised that a chronic zinc deficient state may be reflected in slow growth or height faltering in children. Shorter children may thus be zinc deficient and this may explain why this group had a better response to zinc supplementation. We have previously reported a significant improvement in mucosal integrity in response to zinc supplementation, as assessed by measurements of intestinal permeability.28 It was reported in an earlier study from India that children receiving 40 mg of elemental zinc daily during acute diarrhoea responded with a shorter duration of diarrhoea than a control group.29 The response was linked to a significantly earlier recovery in the children who had lower rectal zinc concentration and were considered to be a zinc deficient subgroup. Improved integrity of the small intestinal mucosa, which we showed earlier,28 may partially explain the improved fluid absorption reflected in reduced stool output and earlier recovery from diarrhoea. In Mexican preschool children zinc supplementation reduced diarrhoeal morbidity.30

Another possibility is that zinc supplementation may promote the rapid clearance of diarrhoeal pathogens from the intestine through improved immunity. Zinc supplementation is known to improve cell mediated immunity and it increases salivary secretory IgA in malnourished children.16 31 Clearance of intestinal parasites such as Strongyloides ratti in zinc deficient rats occurred significantly earlier and more efficiently after zinc supplementation.32 Zinc supplementation has also been found to reduce the duration of infection with rhinovirus in elderly patients.33 It may be assumed that zinc inhibits viral activity but it is difficult to say whether zinc supplementation reduces diarrhoea because of an effect on viruses such as rotavirus, which was present in about one third of our subjects. It is known that diarrhoea may cause growth faltering in children34 by a variety of mechanisms including decreased dietary intake, malabsorption, and loss of endogenous nutrients, and altered metabolism.

The rate of catch up weight gain in our children was greater in those receiving zinc than in the control group. This might be a result of better absorption of nutrients and increased protein synthesis after zinc supplementation. Zinc supplementation of malnourished Jamaican children during nutritional rehabilitation was associated with increased lean tissue synthesis.35 Zinc supplementation also promoted an increased weight gain velocity of 8.8 g/kg/day among children recovering from severe malnutrition in Bangladesh.36 The effect of zinc on diarrhoeal pathogens could reduce loss of endogenous zinc, electrolytes, and water.

In conclusion, our study shows overall weight gain in children with zinc supplementation, an increase in serum zinc in the face of acute diarrhoea, and significant benefit in reduction of the duration of diarrhoea and diarrhoeal stool output among the children who had linear growth faltering and who had lower serum zinc values.

We propose that zinc supplementation is a simple, acceptable, and affordable strategy which should be considered in the management of acute diarrhoea and prevention of growth faltering in children, specially those who are malnourished.

Acknowledgments

This research was supported by the Wellcome Trust (UK) and the International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh (ICDDR,B). The ICDDR,B is supported by countries and agencies which share its concern for the health problems of developing countries. Current donors include: the aid agencies of the Governments of Australia, Bangladesh, Belgium, Canada, Japan, The Netherlands, Norway, Saudi Arabia, Sri Lanka, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States; international organisations including Arab Gulf Fund, Asian Development Bank, the European Union, the United Nations Children’s Fund (Unicef), the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), and the World Health Organisation (WHO); private foundations including Aga Khan Foundation, Child Health Foundation (CHF), Ford Foundation, Population Council, Rockefeller Foundation, Thrasher Foundation, and the George Mason Foundation; and private organisations including East West Inc, Helen Keller International, International Atomic Energy Agency, Lederle Praxis, New England Medical Center, Procter and Gamble, RAND Corporation, Social Development Centre of the Philippines, the Swiss Red Cross, Johns Hopkins University, the University of Alabama at Birmingham, UCB Sidac, Wander AG, and others. We are grateful to Professor R Eeckels, Ex-Director ICDDR,B for his active interest in the study, and to Drs Iqbal Kabir and M A Salam for their suggestions on the manuscript. We acknowledge Mrs Jarin Sultana, Azmira Begum, Sabira Islam, and Quazi Eliza Islam for their careful work during the study, the members of the Clinical Research Centre for their cooperation, and Mr M A Wahed, M Rahman, and F Jahan for their assistance with biochemical analysis. We acknowledge Mr K M Rafique for his help in preparing this manuscript.

Appendix

Composition of diet for acute diarrhoea patients (per litre). Low lactose milk based diet

References

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.