Article Text

PDF

Sports injuries in children: should we be concerned?
  1. P J Helms
  1. Department of Child Health, University of Aberdeen, Foresterhill, Aberdeen AB25 2ZD
  1. Professor Helms.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Despite worrying evidence that British children, like their parents,1 lead a predominantly sedentary life,2 3 concerns continue to be expressed for those children who do take part in organised sport and who may be involved in intensive training from an early age.4 5 Injuries of all types in childhood account for a large part of the workload of accident and emergency departments and result in a significant number of deaths per year. However, deaths from sporting activity in childhood are rare, and are mainly associated with cardiovascular conditions such as hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and congenital coronary artery anomalies in boys.6 However, there remains the possibility that children who undertake intensive training and frequent competition may suffer the long term consequences of acute and overuse injury in later life. Over the past two decades it has been noted that the age of athletes taking part in competition and regular training in sports such as tennis, swimming, and gymnastics has been reducing.4 7This is a likely consequence of the ‘catch them young’ philosophy, the widespread belief that in order to achieve international success at senior level it is necessary to start intensive training well before puberty.4 These concerns have led to the issuing of guidelines for sports participation by children8 and warnings of increasing risk of acute and overuse injuries as children change from varied free play to the repetitive demands dictated by the specialised pattern of movement imposed by a single sport at high level.9 10

What injuries?

During the growth spurt, adolescents are particularly vulnerable to injuries.9 Studies in the early 1980s suggest that between 3 and 11% of school age children were injured each year while taking part in some form of sports activity,11 12 with more recent studies suggesting a higher figure of 22%.13 14 As might be expected boys are more commonly affected than girls.12 14 Physical characteristics may play a part, for example joint laxity is associated with ligamentous injury while tightness of ligaments is more correlated with meniscal injuries and ankle, shoulder, and wrist sprains.15 In adolescence, transient loading to joints may also result in so called exertion injuries which usually resolve over a period of six months without any specific treatment.16 Other so called intrinsic risk factors have been identified including age, sex, and personality. Extrinsic factors that have been identified include type of sport, level of competition, playing surfaces, weather conditions, and provision of protective clothing or equipment.17Matching of opponents is also an important factor. Viewed largely in terms of chronological age, youth sport is often banded by the child’s birth date. However, this does not take biological age differences into account. The potential competitive inequality and increased risk of injury associated with such mismatches are especially evident in contact and collision sports.18 Although minor soft tissue injuries and cuts and abrasions make up the majority of injuries, more serious injuries including acute fractures and stress fractures do occur. It has been suggested that a uniquely vulnerable time for fractures occurs at the age of peak height increase when there may be an imbalance between muscle strength and relative bone strength.19 20 Several studies have reported the occurrence of bone fractures in children involved in a range of sports. The huge variation from 1% in weight training21 to nearly 70% in wrestlers22 highlights one of the problems in identifying the true prevalence of sports injury. These problems include different definitions of injury, whether the study was retrospective or prospective, the intensity of exposure to exercise, and the ability and skill of the individual. The latter issue is of considerable significance as it has been suggested that the reported low injury rates in elite young athletes may be attributed to this factor.23 The immature musculoskeletal system of the growing child results in different patterns of injury from those found in mature adults. Particularly vulnerable sites include the growth plate, the joint surfaces, and sites of musculotendinous insertion.24

Stress fractures in childhood are rare, although the pattern is thought to be different from those found in older children and adults, with most of the studies on stress fractures being performed in young track and field athletes in whom the lower limb and its attachments are particularly vulnerable. A review of a four year experience of 368 such injuries in 324 athletes found that running accounted for almost three quarters of all such injuries, with ball games showing a very low incidence of under 7%.25 There are a wide range of possible injuries of the skeletal system in young athletes which are more the concern of the orthopaedic surgeon or accident and emergency specialist and these have been extensively reviewed.26

Definitions and risks

As there is no clear definition of what constitutes a sports injury,27 it is not surprising that the published prevalence by sport varies widely. Definitions of injury may influence the prevalence and incidence as will the retrospective or prospective nature of the study. The severity is also open to debate as it can be defined as an event causing the athlete to miss a practice session, a competition, or a defined period ranging from a few hours to days or weeks. In a large prospective study of over 450 athletes from four sports, soccer, gymnastics, tennis, and swimming, it was found that injury rates in boys and girls were very similar, with the exception of female gymnasts in whom a higher prevalence was found.23This could have been due to sex differences or to the fact that the majority of coaches are men and that girls were being given less appropriate advice than their male counterparts. However, this prospective study was different from many others in that it assessed elite athletes who were identified by coaches as having international potential. Injury rates were low in this study and were predominantly minor.23 This may have been because of the selection of a talented group of youngsters or because of the more expert coaching in such an elite group. However, in a prospective study of Danish soccer players aged 12–18 years in which a similar definition of injury was used, an incidence of 3.7 injuries per 1000 hours of soccer played was found which was of a similar low order.28 Low rates of injury in the more gifted children could also be explained by selection of individuals with a more robust musculoskeletal system. To clarify the issue of sports related injury, future studies should consider using recently developed indicators, including type of injury, nature and duration of treatment, time lost from sport, school absenteeism, permanent damage, and financial costs.29

Sports specific?

Very few prospective data have been reported for groups of intensively training young people, which prompted the Sports Council to support the training of young athletes (TOYA) study in the mid-1980s. Details of this study and the broad conclusions have been described.30 This longitudinal study surveyed the incidence of injury retrospectively for two consecutive years. Athletes ranged in age from 8 to 18 years and included representatives from soccer, gymnastics, swimming, and tennis. Of the 453 athletes the average incidence of injury in a year was identified as 54 per 100 athletes,23 which was slightly higher than 39 injuries per 100 athletes found in a large American survey.31 Although there are no prospective random community samples of injuries in children engaging in normal day to day activity, considering the very high rate of injury and use of children’s accident and emergency departments, the rates above do not look particularly high. As might be expected the lowest incidence of injury was found in swimmers (37%) and the highest in soccer players (67%). Gymnasts were nearly eight times more likely to be injured in both training and competition than swimmers, whereas soccer players were more likely to be injured during competition than training, a pattern that probably reflects the contact nature of the sport and relatively longer periods spent in competition than training. Swimmers and to a lesser extent male tennis players sustained a substantial number of injuries in activities outside their main sport, and it was likely that most of these occurred during sporting activity in school. There is evidence that combined factors such as poor playing fields, inadequate protective equipment, and insufficient supervision by instructors with limited knowledge may contribute to the incidence of injury in school sport.32 33 Increasing participation in school sport is one of the ‘health of the nation’ targets, and, if a parallel increase in injuries is to be avoided, attention will have to be given to adequate facilities, equipment, and training for those supervising this activity.

Intensive training

Concern has been expressed that the intensity of training is likely to increase the risk of injury. In the TOYA study, as in other similar studies, it was difficult to clearly identify what constituted intensive training. As might be expected, perceived intensity varied considerably between sports but also between coaches within the same sport. In the TOYA study, hours trained per week was used as a criterion of intensity. When children who were considered to be exposed to intensive training, using thresholds agreed by their coaches, were separated from the remainder, no significant differences were found between the injury rates of high and low intensity trainees.34 It would therefore seem that intensive training in elite athletes with good facilities and with experienced coaches is less likely to result in significant injury than less well supervised sporting activity in schools and ad hoc clubs. Of the 492 injuries reported over the two year period in the TOYA study, just over one third were identified as overuse injuries, the remainder being acute. However, there are no long term data available apart from anecdotal reports from individuals with severe overuse injuries from sports such as gymnastics, tennis, and soccer. When overuse injuries occur they tend to be more severe, with an approximate doubling of days off training as a consequence.34

Counting the cost

The majority of injuries are dealt with in the first instance by physiotherapists, and, somewhat surprisingly from the TOYA study, it was found that a large portion of these injuries were treated privately, resulting in considerable costs for families involved.34 Although some sporting bodies such as the British Amateur Gymnastic Association buys medical insurance for its members, only a small minority of individuals took up this option. For those children involved in regular sporting activity there is a potential for a significant financial burden to be added to the financial support required in travelling to and from sporting events. This may well reduce the likelihood of sustained sporting activity in talented young people and is an important issue that needs to be addressed.

In all the detailed studies of reports of injury in specific sporting groups it must be remembered that accidents are extremely common in children and that serious injury and death are much more likely to occur outside the gymnasium, swimming pool, or away from the sports field. Indeed it is much more likely that children are at greater risk of being seriously injured riding their bicycles to sporting activities, skateboarding, roller blading, or travelling in the family car! Although well supervised sporting activity has a low risk of serious injury and is likely to have quite significant health benefits for those taking part, very little information is available on the long term consequences of overuse injury, which could be a concern for such groups as gymnasts and soccer players. Most injuries are acute and self limiting but those overuse injuries that do occur can result in lengthy periods of enforced inactivity and may have long term consequences for adult musculoskeletal health. Set against these possible long term concerns is the proved benefit of vigorous exercise in adolescence and early life35 and the observation that world class male athletes enjoy an extended life expectancy.36

References

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • This is the fourth article in a series on rheumatology.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.