rss
Arch Dis Child 76:334-336 doi:10.1136/adc.76.4.334
  • Original article

Respiratory morbidity from lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis (LIP) in vertically acquired HIV infection

  1. M Sharlanda,
  2. D M Gibbb,
  3. F Hollandb
  1. aPaediatric Infectious Disease Unit, St George’s Hospital, London, bDepartment of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Institute of Child Health, London
  1. Dr Mike Sharland, Paediatric Infectious Disease Unit, 5th Floor, Lanesborough Wing, St George’s Hospital, London SW17 0QT.
  • Accepted 31 December 1996

Abstract

The aim of the study was to define the respiratory morbidity caused by lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis (LIP) in children with vertically acquired HIV infection. A retrospective case note review was performed on 95 children attending three London hospitals. Clinical and radiological evidence of LIP, acute lower respiratory tract infections, and chronic lung disease was obtained using a structured protocol. A diagnosis of LIP had been made in 33%, and an acute admission due to acute lower respiratory tract infection had occurred in 42% of all children (despite 99% taking regular co-trimoxazole prophylaxis). Admission rates because of acute lower respiratory tract infection were significantly higher in the LIP group (0.38 admissions/child year) than in the non-LIP group (0.17 admissions/child year) (p = 0.0002). Encapsulated bacteria (Streptococcus pneumoniae,Haemophilus influenzae) were most frequently isolated. Improved methods of prevention of acute lower respiratory tract infection may help to reduce the severe respiratory morbidity seen in children with LIP and HIV infection.

Lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis (LIP) was first described in association with autoimmune disease in adults.1Histologically there is a diffuse lymphocytic infiltration of the interalveolar septa with proliferation of the bronchus associated lymphoid tissue (BALT). The association of LIP with adult and paediatric HIV infection was demonstrated on lung biopsies performed on individuals presenting with persistent bilateral reticulonodular shadowing on chest x ray.2 3 Severe bacterial infections, especially of the lower respiratory tract, have also been recognised as a major problem in HIV infected children.4 5 The aim of this study was to determine the association between LIP, acute lower respiratory tract infections, and chronic lung disease in children with vertically acquired HIV infection attending three major hospitals in London.

Methods

Children with vertically acquired HIV-1 infection who had received their clinical care from the paediatric infectious diseases units at St George’s Hospital, St Mary’s Hospital, or Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children were identified through the UK national study of HIV infection in children. The case notes were reviewed by a single investigator (MS) using a standard protocol. Children presenting withPneumocystis carinii pneumonia were excluded from the study. Details extracted included dates of diagnoses of LIP and parotitis, details of hospital admissions with acute lower respiratory tract infection, and evidence of chronic lung disease. The following definitions were used:

Lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis was defined as either confirmatory pathology on lung biopsy or a typical radiological appearance of bilateral diffuse reticulonodular shadowing seen on chestx ray for over two months and unresponsive to antimicrobial treatment (fig 1).6 Parotid enlargement (bilateral and persisting for more than three months) was noted.

Figure 1

The chest x ray of lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis in a 5 year old girl with HIV-1 showing the bilateral reticulonodular shadowing.

Acute lower respiratory tract infection was defined in a child requiring admission to hospital with the presence of at least four of the following five signs: fever greater than 38°C; tachypnoea greater than 40 breaths/minute; new clinical chest signs; new radiological signs on chest x ray; and prompt clinical response to antibiotic treatment. Length of hospital stay, and all positive cultures were noted.

Chronic lung disease was defined as the presence of a chronic cough (symptoms persisting for more than three months) plus chronic chest signs (persisting for more than three months), with or without clubbing of the fingernails. Comparison between the children in the LIP and non-LIP groups was made using the χ2 test. Rates of hospital admission (first admissions and recurrent admissions) were compared in the two groups using the normal approximation to the binomial distribution.7

Results

The case notes of 114 vertically HIV infected children who had received their main clinical care from one of the three hospitals were reviewed, covering the period 1984 to 1994. Nineteen children had presented with Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia and were excluded from the analysis. Of the remaining 95 children, 43 were male, and 52 female. Seventy four per cent were black African, 13% white, 10% mixed, and 3% other. Fifty five (58%) were born in the UK, but only 19 were followed up prospectively from birth. Of the children born abroad the median age of arrival in the UK was 2 years (range 0 to 8 years). Thirteen of the 95 children had died. The median age of the 82 surviving children was 4.7 years (range 1.3 to 15.7 years).

LYMPHOCYTIC INTERSTITIAL PNEUMONITIS

A diagnosis of LIP had been made in 31 children (33%), of whom 19 were born in the UK. Only five children had this diagnosis confirmed on open lung biopsy. Age at diagnosis and follow up time since first presentation were similar among children with and without LIP (table1). Among the 19 children born in the United Kingdom, the median age of LIP diagnosis was 1.8 years (range 0.4 to 5.1 years). LIP was diagnosed in 15 of the 39 black African children born in the UK, compared with four of the 16 white or ‘other’ children (χ2 = 0.4, p > 0.5). Parotid enlargement (defined as bilateral and persistent for more than three months) was significantly more common in children in the LIP group (68%) than in the non-LIP group (3%) (χ2= 45.5, p < 0.001). A chronic cough which was present in 32% of children overall and lasted a median of three years was also noted significantly more often in the LIP group (χ2 = 13.2, p < 0.001) (table 1).

Table 1

Respiratory morbidity by lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis (LIP) diagnosis

ACUTE LOWER RESPIRATORY TRACT INFECTIONS

Over the study period of 276 patient years of follow up, 40 children (42%) required 68 admissions for acute lower respiratory tract infections comprising a total of 700 hospital bed days. The admission rate for first and recurrent admission per child year of follow up was 0.38 in children with LIP compared with 0.17 among children without LIP (z score 3.73, p = 0.0002: table 1). Although the median length of admission was similar for the LIP and non-LIP groups, multiple admissions were more frequent in the LIP group. A positive culture was documented from blood culture, sputum, nasopharyngeal aspirate, or on bronchoalveolar lavage during only 24 (35%) of the 68 admissions with acute lower respiratory tract infection. A single organism was isolated in 15 episodes, Streptococcus pneumoniae being the commonest isolate (table 2). Dual pathology was found in nine cases, cytomegalovirus being the most common second isolate. No significant differences were seen between the LIP and non-LIP groups. Of the 95 children, all but one had been recorded as taking regular co-trimoxazole as prophylaxis against pneumocystis pneumonia. Intravenous immunoglobulin had been given to 11/95 children (12%) at some stage of the illness, while 32/95 (34%) had taken zidovudine. Fifteen children (16%) had received bronchodilators, and prolonged courses of steroids had been used in three children, all with severe LIP. During admissions for acute lower respiratory tract infection, intravenous antibiotics were given during 63/68 (93%) of episodes, but ventilation was only required in only 4/68 episodes (6%).

Table 2

Positive microbial cultures detected during 24 of the 68 episodes of acute lower respiratory tract infection, and their site of origin. In 15 children only one organism was detected; in nine children, two organisms were detected

Discussion

Lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis as a manifestation of paediatric HIV disease occurred in nearly one third of children in our study, a similar rate to that reported from North America.2 LIP was originally an AIDS defining diagnosis in the 1987 CDC classification of AIDS in children. In the revised classification of paediatric HIV disease,8 it was recognised that children with LIP as a first AIDS indicator disease had an improved survival compared with other AIDS indicator diseases,6 and LIP has been redefined as a stage B disease indicator. However, this study confirms that LIP is associated with considerable respiratory morbidity. Although the overall rate of acute lower respiratory tract infection in this study (0.25 episodes/child/year of follow up) is the same as that previously reported in HIV infected children,5 the incidence of such infections in children with LIP was twice that observed in the children with no LIP. The number of children with LIP who had recurrent admission for acute lower respiratory tract infection was particularly striking. The incidence of acute lower respiratory tract infections in children with LIP is approximately 10-fold higher than that reported in an American community based study of non-HIV infected children.9 This study provides evidence of the considerable chronic respiratory morbidity associated with LIP. Some children develop chronic lung damage and bronchiectasis, with a clinical picture similar to cystic fibrosis. While bronchodilators may be of some benefit, other specific treatments have not been systematically studied in LIP. Rubinstein et al have reported improved oxygenation in a small number of children with severe LIP after starting steroids,10 but no controlled trials of steroid treatment have been carried out.

The aetiology of LIP remains uncertain. The principal hypotheses suggest that LIP represents an abnormal lymphoproliferative response, either to HIV alone, or due to superinfection with another virus, the most likely candidate being the Epstein-Barr virus.11 12In the majority of children, a presumptive diagnosis of LIP is now made on radiological and clinical grounds. Lung biopsy had been performed in only five children in this study, at a time when there was little experience of LIP in HIV infected children. Parotid enlargement is confirmed as a useful marker for the presence of LIP in paediatric HIV infection.

Both paediatricians and parents need to be aware of the increased risk of pneumonia in children with LIP, and acute infections should be promptly treated with systemic antibiotics and physiotherapy. An improved understanding of the viral aetiology and immunopathology of LIP is required. Development of a scoring system would facilitate multicentre trials. The most urgent management strategies that need to be evaluated are treatment trials of inhaled or oral steroids, combined with the use of long term continuous antibiotic prophylaxis against encapsulated bacteria.

Acknowledgments

We thank Drs J Evans, S Walters, and V Novelli for their help during data collection. The National Study of HIV in Children is supported by AIDS Education and Research Trust (AVERT), and the Department of Health. Dr Diana Gibb is supported by a MRC clinical senior fellowship.

References