Article Text

PDF

Millennium Development Goals: progress in Oceania
  1. John D Vince
  1. Correspondence to Dr John D Vince, Clinical Sciences Division, School of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Papua New Guinea, PO Box 5623, Boroko, National Capital District, Port Moresby 111, Papua New Guinea; johndvince{at}gmail.com

Statistics from Altmetric.com

For the purposes of this commentary, Oceania is understood to encompass the Pacific Island states of Micronesia, Polynesia and Melanesia including Papua New Guinea (PNG) (but excluding the western half of mainland New Guinea, politically a province of Indonesia), Timor Leste, Australia and New Zealand. In geopolitical Oceania (which excludes Timor Leste), 25 countries, 12 with a population <100 000, are scattered over an area of 8 525 989 km2 (figure 1). The total population is 35 670 000, 27.5 million of whom are in Australia and New Zealand. PNG accounts for the large majority of the remainder. The great majority of the population in Australia and New Zealand are urban dwellers, while the majority of the population in the other countries is rural, the people often living in villages with very difficult access on small islands or atolls or in remote mountain ranges.

Figure 1

Map of Oceania (Timor Leste not marked).

The region includes countries with widely differing economies, infrastructure development, education, health service provision, and health indices. Table 1, based on data from Unicef's State of the World's Children and the United Nations Development Programme reports, indicates some of the important indices relating to child health from a selection of the countries.1 ,2 Only one country, Timor Leste, had reached the Millennium Development Goal (MDG)-4 target by 2012, but from a very high under 5 mortality rate in 1990. Australia, New Zealand and Vanuatu may reach the target, but most of the countries are unlikely to do so.

Table 1

Mortality rates and related indices in some Oceania countries

Mortality rates and economic indicators in Australia and New Zealand are similar to those throughout the rest of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries. However, the overall figures mask, as they do in most countries, mortality rates for their disadvantaged population: in the case of Australia, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Island population, which are more than double the national figures. Nevertheless, mortality rates in this population have been reduced by almost 50% since 2002.3

Good child health is dependent on many inter-related factors, the most important of which are living conditions, the level of female literacy, and financing for, provision of, and accessibility to preventative and curative health services. Between 2007 and 2011, the proportion of the gross national product allocated to health varied from 3% in PNG and Fiji to 14% in Kiribati, with the majority of countries in the 5–8% range. In PNG, this translates to US$35–40$ per capita.

Almost all the countries with low mortality have near 100% primary education, with many having high levels of secondary and tertiary education. Countries with higher mortality have poorer education levels, and even then the figures hide important gender disparities. There is often a higher proportion of male than female children enrolled, and girls are less likely than boys to complete primary education. The standard of primary education in a city school in Australia with state-of-the-art internet technology is vastly different from that in a remote village school in PNG, Solomon Islands or Vanuatu, where books and blackboards may be non-existent.

Maternal mortality rates in some of the countries are high, and in PNG, where only 52% of women deliver in health facilities, and in Timor Leste, the rates are alarmingly high. Neonatal mortality rates are correspondingly high, accounting for 50% of infant mortality. The common causes of neonatal death are infection, birth asphyxia and problems associated with low birth weight. The death of a mother puts her child at risk not only of neonatal but also of later infant and child mortality.

Transport systems to provide ready access to health services are essential. However, in many of the smaller island countries, transport is by dinghy or air. In the larger islands, road transport may simply not exist in some areas, and access is either by air to small airstrips or by foot. Where there are roads, they are likely to be unmetalled and at times unusable by vehicles. Security concerns may also hamper the delivery of services in some countries and some areas. Unfortunately, run down, inadequately staffed and inadequately supplied health facilities are common in some of the countries in the region, preventing health service delivery even when access is possible.

For some of the region's countries such as PNG, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu, population growth rates of >2.4% pose a major challenge to the provision of health, education and other services. Some of the smaller countries have much lower growth rates—in some, reflecting outward migration to countries such as Australia and New Zealand.

The leading causes of child mortality in the low-income countries in the region are communicable diseases: pneumonia, meningitis, diarrhoeal disease, malaria and, in some of the countries, tuberculosis (TB). Many deaths can be avoided with simple preventative and curative interventions. EPI programmes (immunisation programmes) are well established in all countries, but achieving high vaccination coverage has proved difficult in some. In several of the countries, fewer than 75% of children are protected by DPT3 (third dose of diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis vaccine, either as ‘triple vaccine’ or incorporated into other multiantigen vaccines), and, although routine measles-containing vaccine coverage at the 95% level required has been reached in a few countries including Fiji and Samoa, it is well below this in several others. Conjugate Haemophilus influenza type b vaccine has been introduced to all the countries, but pneumococcal conjugate vaccines, which have been part of the programme in Australia and New Zealand for some years, have yet to be introduced in most of the Pacific Island countries.

Safe water supplies are still not available for many communities, and the understanding of the importance of hygiene practices is limited in some population groups.

TB is a significant problem in several of the region's countries, with prevalences ranging from 1.7/100 000 in Fiji to 541/100/000 in PNG.4 Mortality rates from TB in children are not easy to find, but, in high-prevalence countries, TB is a significant cause of death. In PNG hospitals, TB accounts for between 7% and 8% of admissions to the children's wards, has disproportionately high bed occupancy, and carries a case fatality of 13%. Multidrug-resistant TB is well established in PNG, presenting additional challenges.

Malnutrition is a significant problem in some of the Oceania countries, with undernutrition estimated to affect 18% of children in PNG, 12% in Solomon Islands and 11% in Vanuatu. As elsewhere in the world, malnutrition contributes both directly and indirectly to mortality.

Countries in the Oceania region report low prevalences of HIV. PNG has a reported prevalence of 0.5% in the reproductive age group, and HIV accounted for 6.3% of the deaths in the paediatric ward at Port Moresby General Hospital in 2013.

While some of the countries in the region have reached or may well reach the MDG target, others have a long way to go. However, it is important to appreciate that progress has been made in all of the countries—often in spite of formidable constraints.5 The introduction and tighter control of the use of effective artemether combination antimalarials in malaria-affected countries and the introduction of insecticide-treated bed nets has led to a reduction in malarial morbidity and mortality. The introduction and appropriate use of oxygen concentrators for provision of oxygen has significantly reduced mortality in children with pneumonia and other severe illnesses. Some countries have well-established child health policies and strategic implementation plans, focusing on common problems and achievable goals. Many countries are focusing attention on reduction of neonatal mortality by simple and practical means. However, for some of the Oceania region countries, there are clear deficiencies in the provision of primary healthcare, and further progress will come not from focusing on sophisticated hospital care but simply by getting the basics of disease prevention and adequate management of the common illnesses right. A functioning heath system that is adequately funded, equipped and staffed will form the basis for continuing progress, but the wider aspects of health—such as education and infrastructure development—are of equal importance.

There are many challenges to continuing progress in many of the Oceania countries. These include dealing with the unmet need for family planning to slow the population growth rate, planning for the effects of climate change (being felt most acutely in the pacific atolls), and ensuring the rights of women, children and disadvantaged communities. Much will depend on the quality and the ability of governance at all levels to ensure equitable distribution of resources and sustainable development, and to minimise damaging environmental and social effects of mineral, petroleum, gas, forestry and other industries.

Paediatricians in the Oceania region have demonstrated commitment to child health in the widest sense—and it is imperative that they continue to do so.

Acknowledgments

I am grateful to Professor Trevor Duke of the Centre for International Child Health, University of Melbourne for his helpful comments.

References

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Competing interests None.

  • Provenance and peer review Commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.